In partnership with
Startups who switch to Intercom can save up to $12,000/year
Startups who read beehiiv can receive a 90% discount on Intercom's AI-first customer service platform, plus Fin—the #1 AI agent for customer service—free for a full year.
That's like having a full-time human support agent at no cost.
What’s included?
6 Advanced Seats
Fin Copilot for free
300 Fin Resolutions per month
Who’s eligible?
Intercom’s program is for high-growth, high-potential companies that are:
Up to series A (including A)
Currently not an Intercom customer
Up to 15 employees
Personal stories are powerful connection tools in customer onboarding.
They demonstrate empathy, build trust, and show that you genuinely understand their world.
But if you get the timing or content wrong, you’re in danger of making yourself the centre of attention.
In a world where AI can handle the technical explanations, your human ability to connect through shared experience becomes incredibly valuable.
Let’s look at how to strategically share stories for valuable impact. ↓
This project helps you build a deliberate approach to using personal stories that strengthens customer relationships without crossing professional boundaries.
Each step ensures your stories serve the customer, not you.
Step 1: Build up a story inventory
Create a simple document with these common onboarding categories:
Technical resistance: Stories about overcoming pushback on implementation approaches
Stakeholder alignment: Times when you navigated competing priorities across departments
Resource constraints: How you've dealt with limited time, budget, or people
Change fatigue: Experiences managing teams overwhelmed by transformation
Early wins under pressure: Situations where you had to prove value quickly
Under each category, write 2-3 short stories (nothing too long) from your own professional experience.
Not embellished. Not dramatic. Just factual.
🔍 Note: You are aiming for recall speed. When a customer describes a challenge, you instantly know if you have a relevant story without scrambling through your memory mid-call or reading off a script.
Step 2: Apply a "them not me" filter
Before you launch into any story, pause and ask yourself:
"Does this help them make a decision or does this just make me look good?"
If the answer leans towards the latter, don't share it.
Your story should do one of three things:
1. Validate what they're feeling (you're not alone in this)
2. Offer a reframe they haven't considered (here's another way to look at it)
3. Provide a specific tactical approach that worked (this is what shifted things for me)
If it does none of those, it's just noise.
Step 3: Develop client story parallels
Aim to build out corresponding client success stories too.
Same challenge. Similar outcome. Different protagonist.
Sometimes the customer needs to hear "others like you have done this" rather than "I've been through this."
Personal stories work when you're building initial connection or when vulnerability will strengthen the partnership.
Client stories work when the customer needs social proof or when they're in a formal decision-making mode.
Having both options means you can read the room and choose appropriately.
If they're casual and open, go personal.
If they're buttoned up and formal, reference the client story instead.
Step 4: Keep it short and concise
If your story takes longer than 20 seconds to tell, it's too long.
Stories in onboarding should not be for entertainment.
They're bridges to the next part of the conversation. We’ve got a job to do after all!
The structure should be:
One sentence for context (when I worked with X type of company)
One sentence for the challenge (they were facing Y)
One sentence for the insight or action (what made the difference was Z)
Then immediately pivot back to them: "Does that resonate with what you're seeing?"
Step 5: Know the situations where personal stories damage trust
There are specific moments when sharing personal experience actively hurts your credibility.
It’s important to be aware of them.
When they're venting frustration about your product. This is not the time to relate. This is the time to acknowledge, take ownership, and focus on solutions. Your story about a similar technical issue just sounds like "this happens all the time."
When you haven't earned the relationship yet. On a first call, you're still establishing credibility. Personal stories before professional credibility makes you seem overly familiar. Lead with competence, then add connection later.
When the story highlights your failure without a clear resolution. Vulnerability is valuable, but unresolved failure stories just transfer anxiety to the customer. They need to trust you'll guide them successfully.
🤓 The Analysis
When you do share a personal story it strengthens the partnership with customers.
The best onboarding professionals understand that stories are tools, not default responses.
What to expect by making these changes:
Stronger customer trust
Faster rapport building
Increased professional credibility
More productive conversations
